Posts Tagged ‘private schools’
on private schools in Australia, the egalitarian nation
Geelong Grammar, Australia’s most expensive private school, apparently
When I was in my mid-twenties I shared a rented house in a small inner suburb of Adelaide called College Park. It was named after what was by far the largest piece of real estate in the area, St Peter’s College. Our street was called Harrow Road, after Eton and Harrow, get it? Other nearby street names were Oxford, Rugby, Trinity, Marlborough and Pembroke. Not a single Skank Lane or Black Boy Alley to be found.
I was reminded of this period on reading Jane Caro’s article, “Class Warfare” in The Monthly magazine for July 2024. So before tackling the article, here’s a story. Walking the streets of College Park I often crossed ‘in-roads’ leading to the high steel-mesh fence that defended St Peter’s College. On the other side of the fence was lots of green ‘sward’ as Alan Bennett would call it, with a very large mansion or palace in the distance, and a few smaller building dotted about – the servants’ quarters perhaps. It all seemed a little unAustralian to me. Anyway, some of these fences also incorporated gates that seemed not to be locked. That was a bit more Australian, and anyway the front of the College was accessible enough – it was a school, after all. So, noticing that there was a rather forlorn-looking asphalted tennis court, partly fenced and sans net, not far inside the palace grounds, I suggested to my house-mates that we might take our racquets and balls and have a few hits. This, I suppose, was an indication of how bored we were.
So we’d been knocking balls to each other for surely no more than twenty minutes (it was a long time ago) when I noticed a figure in the far distance, marching over the sward towards us, from the vicinity of the palace. Looked like trouble, but we carried on regardless. He appeared to be hailing us, but we waited to get a full view of this clearly colourfully dressed individual. By the time we could make sense of his exclamations, I was able to get a fuller picture of this slim forty-ish gentleman in check golfing trousers, grey-green cardigan, and a bright red cravatte which beautifully set off his flame of auburn hair (okay, I only clearly remember the cravatte).
“Boys, boys, you do realise this is private property?!” He may have said much more, but the words ‘private property’ and the sense of real astonishment in his voice is all I clearly remember, and the more my memory repeats to me those two words, the more Pythonesque his voice sounds. Of course we slunk off with a bad grace, but the memory, and my fantasy of hoisting the fellow with his own petard, is, for better or worse, the most persistent feature for me of that period – though I’ve since learned that a petard is a bomb, not a cravatte.
So the god of private property still looms large in ‘classless’ Australia – and the larger the property the more powerful the god.
Jane Caro’s article begins with a quote.
“We ask public schools to compete against private ones, but we do not give them the funding or resources to do so,” says the principal of a comprehensive public secondary school. “We then fill them with the most disadvantaged – and so most expensive to teach – students, including those rejected or expelled from publicly subsidised private schools. Then we blame public schools for struggling. No wonder so many of our principals and staff despair.”
Caro goes on to describe a scandalous funding situation regarding public v private schools, with remarks such as ‘no other nation funds education the way we do, yet most Australians remain blissfully ignorant of just what an outlier we are’, and ‘no other [private] schooling system anywhere enjoys such largesse for so little reciprocal cost’. Count me in as one of the blissfully ignorant, and I’ve been tsk-tsking about the USA’s underfunded public education system, and its role in letting down those who might otherwise have seen through Trump’s bullshit (but then there’s their awful public health system, their ultra-low minimum wages, their massive incarceration rates…).
Having said that, and being prepared to accept Caro’s analysis, I’m disappointed that there’s a lack of actual hard data or references in her article (or in any other of The Monthly’s articles). The magazine might employ the excuse that these are only opinion pieces – but they’re clearly not, they’re making factual claims. The Economist, another mag I read from time to time, cites references within its articles (‘according to x..’, ‘statistics from the bureau of y show…’), which might be inelegant, but useful for valiant truth-seekers like me.
So here’s a tantalising and shocking quote from The Australia Institute, a public policy think tank:
In 2024, the Commonwealth Government will spend an estimated $29.1 billion on schools in Australia. More than half of this – $17.8 billion – will go to private schools.
More than half that private money – $9.9 billion – is earmarked for Catholic schools, in a nation regarded internationally as one of the least religious in the world. How can this be happening?
According to the 2021 census census, just under 20% of our population identifies as Catholic. That number strikes me as unbelievably high (I’ve also met many who identify as Catholic but don’t ‘practise’ the religion), but it has been falling quite rapidly since the 70s.
Unsurprisingly, Independent Schools Australia – presumably an advocacy website for independent schools – claims that all this malarky about funding is just mischiefy myth-making. Here’s a quote from theirs:
FACT: On average, Independent schools receive around half the level of government funding of public schools.
Hmmm. So, one of these claims is not like the other. Clearly, one would expect independent schools to receive far less funding because they’re fee-paying schools which tend to advertise themselves as superior. And those fees can be pretty hefty – the still all-male St Peters College, with the swards and the cravattes, charges (in 2024) $17,770 per annum for Prep students (that’s pre-Reception!) up to $31,770 for year 12. And if you’re a boarder, that’s an extra $28,600 on top. I’m not sure if that includes uniforms and cravattes. So, while I’m skeptical of the above-mentioned ‘fact’, I have to wonder why independent schools receive any funding at all.
Thinking on this has dredged up another memory. The school I attended in my last three years of primary education – Elizabeth Field Primary – hit the headlines of South Australia’s principal daily paper, some years after I left the building, as the most violent school in the state, which came as a great surprise to me, as I’d noticed nothing more than the odd mumble or sneer in my time there. However I do recall, from those days, outlining to my sister a story I planned to write about a student uprising which left most of the teachers dead or dying on a field of gore. But isn’t that every schoolboy’s fantasy?
The evidence, in any case, appears to support Caro’s essay. ABC News reported late last year on an analysis by the Australian Education Union. It argues that ‘Australian private schools are overfunded by $800 million this year while there is a funding shortfall of $4.5 billion for public schools’, and finds that Tasmanian schools are particularly hard hit. Further, it finds that ‘chronic underfunding of public schools in every state and the Northern Territory is expected to worsen over the next five years’. It should be noted that centre-left Labor governments are in power in every state and territory in Australia, except for Tasmania.
So, what is to be done? Australia’s politicians, especially those in the top jobs, are mostly private school educated and reluctant to despoil their own nests – so it’s the usual situation of a politics run by elites for elites, which has long been a problem of ‘representative’ democracy as opposed to participatory democracy. So the problem won’t be solved, obviously, by voting ‘this lot’ out, as the conservatives are even more beholden to private school education. Being informed and making a fuss, a noise that can’t be ignored, is the best I can come up with, though I’m not much of a noise-maker myself. Education is so important, it’s the key to having as good, as informed an electorate as possible. And currently Australia’s education system, and its funding, makes a mockery of our claim to be an egalitarian nation.
I suppose I should send this to a politician, for what it’s worth.
References
Federal funding for private schools
DISPELLING MYTHS